It wasn’t easy picking a best overall healthy peanut butter, but Crazy Richard’s ultimately won out because it hits all the right notes: It’s made from just one simple ingredient — peanuts — tastes delicious, and is easy to find at most major grocery stores and online.
Healthline writer and registered dietitian Rachael Ajmera, MS, RD, vouched for Crazy Richards, “This peanut butter is one of my favorites, thanks to its rich, peanutty flavor and straightforward list of ingredients.”
The brand offers both creamy and crunchy versions, so you can pick based on your personal preferences. Additionally, it’s gluten-free and made without any added sugar or palm oil.
However, pantry peanut butter fans be warned, according to Ajmera, “It can get a little runny if you leave it out, so I recommend sticking it in the fridge if you prefer a thicker, more spreadable texture.”